Mariah Carey Faces $20 Million Lawsuit Over ‘All I Desire for Christmas Is You

Songwriter Andy Stone, who wrote a music with the equivalent title 5 years earlier than Carey’s holiday basic, accuses singer of copyright infringement

Daniel Kreps
Jun 05, 2022

Mariah Carey
CBS by process of Getty Photos

Mariah Carey is facing a $20 million lawsuit over her holiday basic “All I Desire for Christmas Is You,” as one other songwriter who also released a music with that title has sued the singer for copyright infringement.

In the lawsuit filed Friday in a Original Orleans federal court docket, Andy Stone — who wrote, recorded and released an even music titled “All I Desire for Christmas Is You” under the identify Vince Vance and the Valiants in 1989, 5 years sooner than Carey’s hit — claims that Carey and her co-creator Walter Afanasieff created a “spinoff” version of his music with out permission. Afanasieff and Sony Tune are listed as co-defendants on the lawsuit.

The copyright infringement lawsuit, obtained by Rolling Stone, bases its claims on the incontrovertible reality that the 2 songs fraction the equivalent title: Stone’s lawsuit would no longer issue the 2 songs sound alike, as they fraction exiguous similarity musically or lyrically. As an different, Stone believes that, as the creator of a music called “All I Desire for Christmas Is You” that predated Carey’s beget single, he has the copyright on subsequent works bearing that title. “Defendants knew or must beget known of Plaintiff’s copyright,” the lawsuit states, collectively with that Stone’s single obtained “intensive airplay” at some level of the 1993 Christmas season.

Regardless of the incontrovertible reality that Carey’s “All I Desire for Christmas Is You” changed into as soon as a Billboard Hot 100 Quantity One hit, the video has a blended 1 billion views on YouTube and over 1 billion streams on Spotify, and the music unofficially and yearly marks the genuine launch of the vacation season, Stone’s attorneys issue within the lawsuit that they didn’t attain out to Carey’s correct team till April 2021. A conclude and desist adopted, and changed into as soon as no longer well-liked.

Attorneys for Stone and reps for Carey and Sony Tune did no longer with out extend answer to Rolling Stone’s request for commentary.

The lawsuit — which changed into as soon as filed in Original Orleans on legend of that’s the put, in April 2022, Stone purchased a duplicate of Carey’s 1994 album Merry Christmas that featured her “All I Desire for Christmas Is You” — seeks “the profits, beneficial properties and advantages derived by the Defendants on legend of willful copyright infringement, as well to punitive damages and compensation for the damages sustained in an quantity no longer lower than $20,000,000.00.”

As Time limit notes, the backbone of Stone’s lawsuit may perhaps face factors in fraction on legend of there are 177 copyrighted songs with the title “All I Desire for Christmas Is You,” collectively with dozens that had been written decades sooner than Vince Vance and the Valiants’ version. “Tune titles aren’t entitled to copyright protection,” mental property rights approved knowledgeable Pamela Koslyn told Time limit.

Overview the 2 “All I Desire for Christmas Is You” in request below:

From Rolling Stone US.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Back to top button